Key Takeaways
Skid Slayer and Reel Paper match on ply, sheets, and fibre, so the real choice is unbleached versus bleached white, with Reel priced a little lower. (148 chars)
Both are 100% bamboo, three-ply, 300-sheet, plastic-free, FSC-certified rolls sold by subscription.
The core difference is processing: Skid Slayer is unbleached and tan, Reel is bleached bright white.
Reel uses elemental chlorine free whitening; Skid Slayer skips the whitening stage entirely.
Reel is usually a little cheaper per 100 sheets and is a certified B Corp with a reforestation program.
Choose Skid Slayer for genuinely unbleached bamboo; choose Reel for a white sheet at a lower price.
Skid Slayer vs Reel Paper: what is the real difference?
Skid Slayer and Reel Paper are unusually similar products, so the honest headline is that they match on almost every specification and split on one big thing: colour and processing. Both are 100% bamboo, three-ply rolls with 300 sheets, both are plastic-free and FSC-certified, and both sell direct with a subscription. The decisive difference is that Skid Slayer is unbleached and arrives tan, while Reel is bleached to a bright white.
That single difference is the whole reason to pick one over the other on the product itself, because so much else is a tie. If you specifically want genuinely unbleached bamboo tissue that skips the whitening stage, Skid Slayer is built for exactly that. If you are happy with a clean white sheet, Reel delivers that with a well-documented process.
There are two other honest points of separation worth stating up front, and both lean slightly toward Reel. Reel tends to be a little cheaper per 100 sheets, and it is a certified B Corp with a reforestation partnership, which matters to some buyers. So this is not a case of one roll being clearly better; it is a genuine trade-off between unbleached processing on one side and price plus certain credentials on the other. The sections below lay out each factor fairly.
How do the specifications compare?
On paper, these two are close to twins, and it is worth being clear about that rather than manufacturing differences that do not exist. Both are made from 100% bamboo, both are three-ply, and both carry 300 sheets per roll, so on ply and sheet count they are a straight tie, and neither wins on quantity.
The similarities continue through the rest of the spec sheet. Both are plastic-free, both use recyclable or compostable inner cores, both are FSC-certified for responsibly sourced bamboo, and both are sold primarily direct to consumers with a subscription option. Because ply drives comfort and durability, it is worth noting that both sit in the cushioned three-ply category rather than thin single-ply, and our comparison of three-ply versus two-ply bamboo toilet paper explains why that matters for everyday use.
Where they diverge is not the numbers but the finish. Skid Slayer leaves its bamboo unbleached, so the sheet is a natural tan, while Reel whitens its bamboo to a conventional white. Reel also publishes a 4 by 4 inch sheet size; Skid Slayer buyers should check the current pack for exact sheet dimensions. In short, if you lined up the two spec sheets, the ply, fibre, sheet count, packaging, and certification lines would read almost identically, and your eye would land on the one row that actually differs: bleached versus unbleached.
Is Reel Paper bleached or unbleached?
Reel Paper is bleached, not unbleached, and this is the pivotal fact in the comparison. According to Reel's own published information, its bamboo is whitened using elemental chlorine free processing, the method that produces a bright white sheet without using raw chlorine gas. That is a legitimate, widely used approach, and Reel is transparent that its paper is whitened this way.
Skid Slayer takes the other path and skips the whitening stage altogether, which is why it is tan rather than white. The difference between the two is exactly the difference between elemental chlorine free bleaching and no bleaching at all, a distinction explained in the reference on bleaching of wood pulp. Reel removes the natural colour with a chlorine-free method; Skid Slayer leaves the natural colour in place. Our guide to bleach-free toilet paper without harsh additives covers what skipping that stage does and does not mean.
To be fair to Reel, elemental chlorine free whitening is recognised as a responsible modern method, and Reel also states its paper is made without added dyes, inks, fragrances, BPA, or formaldehyde, so a white Reel sheet is a clean product, not a heavily treated one. The honest framing is therefore not that Reel is bad, but that it is bleached while Skid Slayer is not. If avoiding the whitening step entirely is your priority, Skid Slayer wins that point clearly; if you simply prefer a white sheet and are comfortable with a chlorine-free process, Reel is a sound choice.
Which is cheaper, Skid Slayer or Reel Paper?
On price, Reel is usually the cheaper of the two, and it would be dishonest to spin that otherwise. Comparing the 24-roll boxes at the time of writing, Reel lists around $43.99 for a one-time order and about $36.99 on subscription, while Skid Slayer's 24-roll box is around $48.96 one-time and about $41.62 on subscription. Since both boxes hold 24 rolls of 300 sheets, Reel comes out a little lower on the fair measure of unit price per 100 sheets.
The gap is modest rather than dramatic. Both land in the same premium bamboo band, and both reward subscribing and buying the larger box, so neither is a budget product. But if the lowest price between these two specific brands is your deciding factor, Reel currently has the edge, and an honest comparison has to say so plainly. Prices change, so it is always worth checking the current figures before you buy.
What you are weighing against that price gap is the unbleached difference. Skid Slayer costs a little more, and in exchange you get the genuinely unbleached sheet that Reel does not offer in this line. Whether that is worth the small premium is a personal call: for a buyer who specifically wants unbleached bamboo, it often is; for a buyer indifferent to colour who wants the lower price, Reel makes sense. The point is that the price difference is real and small, and it buys a specific processing difference.
What about mission, certifications, and brand credentials?
Both brands have real sustainability credentials, and here Reel carries a couple of extras worth acknowledging. Both are FSC-certified for responsibly sourced bamboo and both use plastic-free packaging, so on those measures they are level. Beyond that, Reel is a certified B Corp and runs a reforestation program, contributing to tree-planting projects with each box sold, which are genuine points in its favour for a mission-minded shopper.
Crediting that plainly matters, because a fair comparison does not hide a rival's strengths. If B Corp certification and an active giving or planting program are important to you, Reel has a documented edge there, and that is a legitimate reason some buyers choose it. Skid Slayer's story is centred more on the product itself, a straightforward unbleached, additive-light bamboo roll, backed by FSC sourcing, rather than on a separate certification badge or planting scheme.
So the credentials picture is not one-sided in Skid Slayer's favour; if anything, Reel leads on formal certifications and mission programs. Where the two are equal is the core sustainability basics of bamboo fibre, FSC sourcing, and plastic-free packaging, and our guide on bamboo versus recycled toilet paper puts those shared fundamentals in context. The takeaway is to weigh Reel's certification and planting credentials against Skid Slayer's unbleached product focus and decide which set matters more to you.
Which should you choose, Skid Slayer or Reel Paper?
Because these two are so evenly matched, the choice comes down to a single clear question: do you want unbleached bamboo or a bleached white sheet, and how much does a small price difference matter to you? Both are quality three-ply, 300-sheet, 100% bamboo, plastic-free, FSC-certified rolls, so you are not choosing between good and bad, but between two good products with one meaningful difference.
Choose Skid Slayer if you specifically want genuinely unbleached bamboo that skips the whitening stage, keeps the sheet as plain as possible, and shows the fibre's natural tan colour. That is its defining strength and the one thing Reel does not offer in this line. You can see the full specification on the page for its unbleached bamboo toilet paper, and compare pack sizes in the wider bamboo tissue range.
Choose Reel if you prefer a white sheet, want the slightly lower price between the two, and value its B Corp certification and reforestation program. Both are honest picks, and neither is a mistake. The most useful way to decide is to be clear about your own priority: unbleached and additive-light points to Skid Slayer, while white plus lowest price plus formal certifications points to Reel. Match the roll to what you actually care about, and you will be happy with either.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Skid Slayer or Reel Paper better?
Neither is simply better; they suit different priorities. Both are 100% bamboo, three-ply, 300-sheet, plastic-free, FSC-certified rolls. Skid Slayer is unbleached and tan, which is its main advantage, while Reel is bleached white, usually a little cheaper, and a certified B Corp with a reforestation program. Choose based on whether unbleached processing or price and certifications matter more to you.
Is Reel Paper unbleached?
No. Reel Paper's bamboo toilet paper is bleached white using elemental chlorine free whitening, according to Reel's own information. It is made without added dyes, inks, fragrances, or BPA, so it is a clean white sheet, but it is not unbleached. If you want genuinely unbleached bamboo that skips the whitening stage, Skid Slayer is the unbleached option between the two.
Do Skid Slayer and Reel Paper have the same number of sheets?
Yes. Both carry 300 sheets per roll and both are three-ply, so on ply and sheet count they are an exact tie. Neither brand offers more paper per roll than the other in these products. Since the quantities match, your decision really comes down to unbleached versus bleached white, price, and each brand's certifications rather than sheet count.
Which is cheaper, Skid Slayer or Reel Paper?
Reel Paper is usually a little cheaper. At the time of writing, its 24-roll box is around $43.99 one-time or about $36.99 on subscription, versus roughly $48.96 and $41.62 for Skid Slayer's 24-roll box. Both hold 24 rolls of 300 sheets, so Reel is modestly lower per 100 sheets. Prices change, so check current figures, but Reel currently has the small price edge.
Are both Skid Slayer and Reel Paper septic safe?
Yes. Both are standard bamboo toilet papers designed to break apart in water and flush normally, so both are suitable for septic systems and regular plumbing in normal use. Neither being unbleached nor bleached changes that, since dispersal, not colour, determines septic safety. As with any toilet paper, use sensible amounts and never flush wipes alongside them.
Resources
-
Bleaching of wood pulp: explains elemental chlorine free whitening, the method Reel uses, versus leaving fibre unbleached like Skid Slayer.
-
Forest Stewardship Council: the certification both brands carry, verifying responsibly sourced bamboo.
-
Unit price: why comparing cost per 100 sheets is the fair way to judge which roll is cheaper.
-
B Corporation (certification): the third-party certification Reel holds, covering verified social and environmental standards.
We make unbleached 3-ply bamboo toilet paper and test it obsessively, jar tests, tear tests and septic-owner feedback included. Mission: cleaner wipes, zero plastic, no skid left behind. More about us.